The Agonist
https://journals.tplondon.com/agonist
<p class="justify"><strong><em>The Agonist</em> </strong>is an Open Access journal dedicated to the investigation of Nietzsche’s works and his influences on contemporary culture in different fields such as arts, philosophy, religion, and science, to name only a few. In the spirit of his philosophical pursuit, the journal publishes essays within Nietzsche scholarship and beyond academia. The journal also examines Nietzsche’s relationship to figures from previous ages, as we have done in one of our issues entitled “Nietzsche in History.” Furthermore, Nietzsche continues to inspire many artistic, cultural, and intellectual movements. We explore his influences on such movements with authors who work in these areas, as we have done in the issue on Nietzsche and Trans- and Post-humanism. In addition to essays and book reviews, we also publish interviews and exegeses. We publish only previously unpublished materials. <em>The Agonist</em> is an international peer-reviewed journal, which is read all over the world. </p> <p class="justify"><em>The Agonist</em> is published by <a href="https://tplondon.com"><em>Transnational Press London</em></a> on behalf of the <a href="http://nietzschecircle.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Nietzsche Circle</em></a>. The journal is made available only through the modest subscription collections we receive from libraries and readers. If you believe in the mission of this journal, we kindly ask you to support us.</p> <p class="justify"><strong>Tha Agonist </strong>is an <a href="https://journals.tplondon.com/agonist/about#oanchor">Open Access</a> publication, allowing users to freely access, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to full-text articles for any lawful purpose without requiring permission from the publisher or author. </p> <p class="justify"><em>The Agonist</em> is published twice a year in May and December. </p> <p class="justify"><em>The Agonist</em> is indexed by <a href="http://kanalregister.hkdir.no/publiseringskanaler/erihplus/periodical/info?id=502116" target="_blank" rel="noopener">ERIH Plus</a> and <a href="https://ideas.repec.org/s/mig/agonjl.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">RePEc</a>. </p> <p class="m_4286799904046857366MsoNoSpacing"><strong>ISSN 2752-4132 (Print) </strong><strong>ISSN 2752-4140 (Online)</strong></p>Transnational Press Londonen-USThe Agonist2752-4132<p>All rights reserved.</p>Editors' Foreword
https://journals.tplondon.com/agonist/article/view/3476
Anthony Kosar
Copyright (c) 2024 Author, The Agonist, Transnational Press London
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
2024-12-042024-12-0418210.33182/agon.v18i2.3476Leveling vs. Levelness
https://journals.tplondon.com/agonist/article/view/3404
<p>In this essay, I follow the work of Jonas and Yacek in <em>Nietzsche’s Philosophy of Education</em> by contrasting a process of <em>leveling</em> in morality and education with an approach to <em>levelness</em> in teaching and learning as these relate to the educational philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche. While Nietzsche would oppose the former due to its implied uniform standardization, I argue, with reference to the work of educational psychologist John B. Biggs, that his philosophy of education could sustain an outcomes-based approach to teaching and learning. While I hold that Nietzsche’s reflections on his own teaching practice evidence clear sympathy for such an approach, I consider two potential objections against its ascription to Nietzsche. In response to the deeper, second objection, which considers whether an outcomes-based approach to education entails some form of uniform standardization akin to that implied by the leveling process, I propose that a democratic reading of Nietzsche’s perfectionism together with the model of inclusive excellence proposed by Williams et al. may provide a more fitting standard. I conclude by reflecting on the potential democratic outcomes, as noted by Gurin et al., of developing a Nietzschean approach to teaching and learning based on such a standard of inclusive excellence.</p>Michael Begun
Copyright (c) 2024 Author, The Agonist, Transnational Press London
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
2024-12-042024-12-0418210.33182/agon.v18i2.3404Nietzsche's Pale Criminal Identified
https://journals.tplondon.com/agonist/article/view/3393
<p>As he does in most of his books, in <em>Thus Spoke Zarathustra</em> Nietzsche is unfolding his dedicated resistance to established social standards and moral tenets, though in some sections therein in somewhat less than a clearly developed thematic progression. Thus, early in Part I of <em>Zarathustra</em>, we come across a speech by the eponymous character, titled “On the Pale Criminal,” whose place and relevance to the rest of the text seem to have perplexed every generation of students of Nietzsche’s <em>oeuvre</em> since its initial appearance in print (in 1883).</p> <p>A closer reading of the speech, however, should reveal that the speech’s main character, an (unidentified male) pale-complected criminal who is about to be condemned to death for the capital crime of murder, is not as incongruous as he might seem at first blush — to the rest of the book or to the world of characters we meet later in <em>Zarathustra</em> or in any of Nietzsche’s other texts. Once we correctly identify the reason for his pale complexion, we might more easily determine his motives as well as the identity of his victim. Once, in turn, we grasp these elements, we notice that the criminal is really a personification of Nietzsche’s two other killers of God, namely, the madman we meet in the <em>Gay Science </em>(Sect. 125), and the inexpressible one, the ugliest man he describes in Part IV of <em>Zarathustra</em>. </p>Thomas Jovanovski
Copyright (c) 2024 Author, The Agonist, Transnational Press London
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
2024-12-042024-12-0418210.33182/agon.v18i2.3393Nietzsche’s Philosophy of Political Authenticity as the Key to “Real” Democracy
https://journals.tplondon.com/agonist/article/view/3405
<p>Despite several decades of attempts to interpret and articulate Nietzsche’s political thought, especially its relationship with democracy, there seems to be no convergence in sight. While this might be easily written off as a consequence of that thinker’s tendency for ambiguity and contradiction, I contend that there is in fact a central pillar of Nietzsche’s political philosophy, authenticity. I extract this central emphasis on authenticity by offering a fresh methodological approach. This approach draws our focus to Nietzsche’s technique of inversion as it applies to his critiques of democracy. Nietzsche’s criticism draws us to the core of the tension between his own philosophical project and the reality of democracy in his time. This subsequently reveals what would make for an authentic democracy faithful to Nietzsche’s core philosophical commitments. The gist of Nietzsche’s criticism of democracy is that it is not, in fact, democracy. Yet, as I show, this is not simply critical, as Nietzsche offers a fresh alternative in the wake of this characteristic inversion. This inversion complicates our understanding of the democratic citizen, their needs, and capabilities. As such, I venture to trace the roots of his criticism, how the problem he raises affects contemporary politics, and what his proposed solution in the form of a commitment to authenticity would look like. In the end, I contend that this focus on authenticity as a central pillar of Nietzsche’s political thought will not only clarify his use for political philosophy, but serve as a powerful resource for political theorists looking to use his work to think about democracy.</p>zachary schroeder
Copyright (c) 2024 Author, The Agonist, Transnational Press London
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
2024-12-042024-12-0418210.33182/agon.v18i2.3405Book Review of Conway on Nietzsche's Beyond Good and Evil
https://journals.tplondon.com/agonist/article/view/3474
Dirk Johnson
Copyright (c) 2024 Author, The Agonist, Transnational Press London
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
2024-12-042024-12-0418210.33182/agon.v18i2.3474